Can I Inform My Buddy Her Halloween Costume Is Problematic?

A brand new buddy within the Midwest was invited to an out of doors Halloween get together the place mask-wearing was requested. We went looking for an art-inspired costume for her. However I noticed that she was gravitating towards interval costumes. After the get together, she posted footage on-line. I used to be shocked! She wore a full-blown Scarlett O’Hara-type robe — to a mansion, no much less! If I’d recognized, I might have tried to speak her out if it. This 12 months’s widespread Black Lives Matter protests, together with the normal whitewashing of the antebellum South, make her selection appear insensitive. I’ll be seeing her quickly, and I already really feel awkward. I do know she’ll share particulars of the get together, and I really feel obligated to enlighten her. Any recommendation?


It’s one factor in case your buddy went to the get together dressed as Scarlett O’Hara. Casually masquerading because the heroine of a racist novel and movie during which Black persons are portrayed as comfortable slaves is problematic. Costume events don’t supply sufficient context for racial commentary.

Nevertheless it’s one other factor in case your buddy merely rented a Victorian costume with a crinoline beneath to make the skirt poof out. That model originated in England and have become trendy in lots of locations (with ever bigger hoop skirts) within the mid-19th century. The clothes will not be primarily related slavery or the South. Girls within the North wore them, too.

So, which was she: dressed as a personality, or from an period? Watch out about leaping to racism. (Your need to “enlighten” your buddy sounds condescending.) In the event you’re undecided, ask her: “What was your Halloween costume?” If she says Scarlett, ask if she thought of the racial implications. If not, save your power for clear-cut situations of racism.

Credit score…Christoph Niemann

I broke up with my boyfriend throughout our coronavirus quarantine. Lately, he was identified with inoperable lung most cancers. He begged me to not let him die alone. So I now have frequent video chats with him, accompany him to medical doctors’ appointments and even stayed in a single day within the hospital with him after he was admitted for pneumonia. The issue: He thinks we’re again collectively once more and desires to renew our intercourse life (which his physician blessed). I don’t have these emotions for him anymore, however I don’t need to damage him, both. Ought to I’ve mercy intercourse with him or inform him I’m not into him?


Neither! By your variety habits, you’ve proven that you simply’re and dependable buddy to your ex. Inform him you need to proceed supporting him throughout this difficult interval, however you haven’t modified your thoughts in regards to the breakup.

Now, this will likely damage his emotions and even make him offended with you. Give him time to work by way of his feelings, however don’t sleep with him out of pity. If I had been in your ex’s place, I might worth a terrific buddy greater than a lover who was solely performing the half. Wouldn’t you?

Throughout the pandemic, our three youngsters satisfied us to undertake a pet from our native animal shelter. Spoiler alert: Elevating a pet is far more durable than we thought. And ours is harmful. We’re contemplating returning him to the shelter, however we really feel responsible about it and our children don’t need us to. What ought to we do?


I believe you are feeling responsible about returning the pet to the shelter since you ought to. Whenever you adopted him, you made a dedication to the canine, the shelter and your loved ones to offer house for him. Going again in your promise too simply can be dangerous for everybody.

Name the shelter and inform the adoption coordinator that you simply’re having actual hassle with the pet and need assistance. The shelter could supply help or join you with a coach. I do know that elevating a pet is tough work. However till you’ve tried your finest, it will be improper to return him. (And relying on the shelter, doing so could have lethal penalties for the pet.)

I’m the sister of the person who wrote to you final week, desirous to take again a now invaluable {photograph} from our mother and father’ property as a result of he gave it to them a few years in the past. He was proper when he stated his siblings objected, however neither he nor you explored why that’s. My sister devoted untold hours to taking good care of our mother and father. And I gave them substantial monetary assist to permit them to remain of their house. Our brother was largely lacking in motion. Further ideas now?


I’m glad you wrote. Household conditions are virtually all the time extra complicated than a single anecdote can convey. That’s why I attempt to not decide anybody and steered that your brother depart the {photograph} in your mother and father’ property.

However now that I’ve you, let me encourage you to sit down down together with your siblings (when it’s secure to try this) and get past this battle. You’ve all suffered an enormous loss with the dying of your mother and father, and your assist for one another could also be way more invaluable than any Eggleston {photograph}. (And I like Eggleston!) It’s simply stuff.

For assist together with your awkward state of affairs, ship a query to, to Philip Galanes on Fb or @SocialQPhilip on Twitter.

Supply hyperlink

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply